the disappearing genius

Fox Boss Forgets Own ‘Sci-fi Isn’t Funny’ Rule in Greenlighting ‘Meet Dave’

7:30AM Defamer Hollywood | Patrick Goldstein is getting kind of good at this blogging thing! After a busy week tipping the world off to the wit and wisdom of censor nonpareil Joan Graves and catching Alan Horn sharpening his ax for Where the Wild Things Are, he spent Monday afternoon taking on the Eddie Murphy Problem. “Murphy has pulled off an almost unprecedented achievement with Meet Dave,” Goldstein notes. “He’s delivered a movie that even 20th Century Fox couldn’t market.”

Why You Don’t Care About Eddie Murphy

10:15AM Defamer Hollywood | We needed a little time today to digest our feelings after the miserable box-office showing of Meet Dave, whose free-fall over the weekend resulted in the ugliest opening of Eddie Murphy’s career. Not having seen it, we have to assume that $5.1 million gross aside, the film is at least superior to Norbit (not to mention Vampire in Brooklyn, Pluto Nash and a sprinkling of other Murphy misfires over the years). We’d even venture to say it’ll be better than Beverly Hills Cop IV, the PG-rated abomination to which Murphy and Brett Ratner are attached for Paramount. Certainly it’s better than The Love Guru, whose own beleaguered comic icon Mike Myers had flowers and a thank-you note on Murphy’s porch by sometime Sunday afternoon. More »