Print

Fat Or Thin, Mary-Kate Just Can’t Win

Remember the prolonged outrage-masked-as-concern over Mary-Kate Olsen’s shrinking body? Well, it’s back, but this time its directed toward her fleshy frame. What’s the poor thing gotta do to keep the tabloids off her back?

Our very own NW has a cover with the star looking like she’s put on a few kilos. Given all that talk of anorexia a few years ago, you’d think that would be good, right? Wrong! The caption looks forward to the day she gets “healthy.” Just last Wednesday Star also did the “Mary-Kate is fat” story, calling her weight gain shocking and saying “bye-bye billion dollar looks, hello bloat”.

Star has a long history of railing on Mary-Kate’s weight. It started in 2004, when they ran a cover saying she was too thin because of drugs.

They finally believed the actress’ claims of anorexia in 2007 (see cover above), but did so by chastising her “stick thin legs” and wondering what is the best way to get her back to health.

Then, in 2008, they did an about face, saying she’s headed back to rehab because of drinking and drugs.

There are really only six stories in a gossip glossy: diet (either too skinny or too fat), drugs, boyfriends, weddings, pregnancy and deaths. So just wait, they’re soon going to say that the “bloat” is from drugs or bulimia or pregnancy or (gasp) all three! Maybe if everyone wasn’t so obsessed with what she’s eating, her weight would even itself out naturally. Why not go after Jonah Hill. He’s overweight and probably much more in danger of a heart attack than Mary-Kate is in danger of anything other than wearing a bad outfit.

Comments (AU Comments | US Comments)

  • PikaDar Brisetout

    @Nice Beaver: Dude, that's *so* sick.

  • wundersmack

    "What's happened to Mary-Kate"? Whatever she damn well pleases! She's a multi-gazillionaire.

    wundersmack

  • Lulupasternak

    "Maybe if everyone wasn't so obsessed with what she's eating, her weight would even itself out naturally."

    And maybe pigs will start sky diving.

    Lulupasternak

  • Vivien Smith-Smythe-Smith

    Well?! Was Britney a sexaholic?

  • jbk

    If we're voting, she looks MUCH hotter in the skinny legs with the fuck-me heels than the Kathleen Turner face. Thanks.

    jbk

  • Beppo

    @scroll_lock: HAHAHAHA.

    Beppo

  • Conchie Birdie

    I blame the NYTimes article on MK & Ash for reminding Star that they still exist. Or else, and I am not kidding you, I believe they have a permanent rotation of celebs they label "headed for rehab" or "anorexic."

  • LeeroySpitzer

    @Gabriel Snyder: I'm sure if you'd let him tell you the whole story you'd see how heartwarming it is.

  • LeeroySpitzer

    @Cicada: Oh, you'd change your mind once you got a glimpse of their giant schlongs and Ed Hardy gear.

  • Gabriel Snyder

    @Nice Beaver: Yes, a rape joke is going to get you banned.

  • Nice Beaver

    @Encantada: I think you catch my drift ; )

  • Encantada

    @Nice Beaver: You mean, abduct her and hold her hostage while you rape and impregnate her throughout her adolescence and young adulthood, forcing her to live in a squalid backyard without access to education or medical attention? Do you have a sister? Children of your own? You really need help, but in the meantime you should be banned from this site.

    Encantada

  • Cicada

    Thank you Star magazine editors, for affirming my misanthropy.

  • trucha

    @Paul.B.Dodd: I was thinking Zelda Rubinstein

    trucha

  • scroll_lock

    The Enquirer's lead story is about John Edwards's love child's love/hate relationship with strained peas.

  • scroll_lock

    More importantly, what are my odds in that $50K prize deal?

  • aLostLady

    @LatestBy: Odd that there's only the one story for that tag, because that person sounds much more interesting.

  • Deric

    And yet, Laurel and Hardy remain comedic geniuses 'til this day. Bastards.

  • Paul.B.Dodd

    She kind of looked like a blonde Delta Burke in that picture. I can dig it.

    Paul.B.Dodd

  • kookla

    I'm really concerned about James Gandolfini. Seriously, how many calories a day is that fat ass hoarding?

  • resipsaloquacious

    What's Kathleen Turner doing on the cover of an Aussie tabloid?

  • misslinda

    Oh the horror, MK looks like an adult instead of a 12-year-old girl. Now if she could only get that Heath Ledger dot and white rectangle removed from her breasts...

    (last Star cover)

  • LatestBy

    Forget Mary-Kate, can we talk about how bloated that Mark-Kate person in the tag looks?

  • hilikusopus

    Let the girl eat ousecream [sic] if she wants!

    hilikusopus

  • Nice Beaver

    Yowzah! Her new fleshy look is makin' me wanna "keep her out back in a series of sheds for 18 years" if ya know what I mean.

  • TubOfTaft

    Whenever she feels bloated, she can add an Ashley name tag to her ensemble.

    TubOfTaft

  • Fancy Pants

    Mary Kate is looking like my Great Aunt Bertha. They dress the same too.

Post Your Comments

Got something to say? There are two ways to comment:

1. Guests

Click here to comment instantly.

2. Facebook Users

Click below to comment using your Facebook account.

We're looking for comments that are interesting, substantial or highly amusing. If your comments are excessively self-promotional, obnoxious, or even worse, boring, you will be banned from commenting. All comments are moderated.