Does Judd Apatow Really Have This Man to Thank For 'Superbad'?
Posted by STV at 4:10 AM on August 1, 2008

You're nobody in this town until you've been ripped off, and even then you're just a little more bitter nobody until an actual, attributable success comes along. According to a profile today in indieWIRE, director Alex Holdridge can finally lay claim to both stages in his accelerating career arc: His funny, lyrical LA romance In Search of a Midnight Kiss opens theatrically tomorrow in New York (Aug. 22 in Los Angeles), several years after a less-auspicious development left him burned at the Sony gates.
Not long after his micro-budget debut Wrong Numbers hit at the 2001 South by Southwest film festival, Holdridge said he had fielded calls from every major studio looking to adapt his comedy about "unruly teens trying to buy beer for a party on their last night of high school" for Hollywood. Sony eventually hired him to write the script on spec, which apparently took a couple years too many for the studio's taste, as Holdridge discovered when he heard about a new Sony project called Superbad:
That was the last straw. As far as he could tell, Wrong Number had been co-opted by Judd Apatow and company.
"It was devastating," Holdridge recalls, hesitant to accuse any particular individual of ripping him off. "Their script was different. Our script was fucking awesome, but you can't copyright a concept." Holdridge suspects the executives at Sony may have suggested his idea to more established Hollywood comedic forces, but he places some of the blame in his own lap. "I have some responsibility because I went and made another movie," he says. "I don't want to complain. What if we just had the same idea?"
Yeah, what if? It's not like Midnight Kiss doesn't owe its own life to Before Sunrise/Sunset, Manhattan and a few other couples-gabbing-in-the-streets classics. And Apatow is the Comedy Person of the Year, after all. But as Holdridge alludes to in the profile, Wrong Numbers is illegal to screen since Sony picked it up seven years ago. We can't wait for the double feature when the time finally comes — and as much as we appreciate his discretion under the circumstances, we're fairly sure it will come.
[Photo: Getty Images]

Comments (AU Comments · US Comments)
There are currently no AU comments for this post.
metroville
Posted 5:05 AM 1/8/08
Judging by the title of his latest film, it appears as though this guy hopes to corner the market on goal-oriented nighttime stories.
metroville
drinkypuss
Posted 5:04 AM 1/8/08
Yeah, but does "wrong numbers" have McLovin?
drinkypuss
kepster
Posted 5:02 AM 1/8/08
I remember reading that Seth Rogen and his writing partner had started working on "Superbad" when they were 13 years old. After seeing the movie I thought this explained everything.
kepster
junkie
Posted 4:57 AM 1/8/08
At least he didn't tell Apatow to get cancer.
junkie
Little Mintz Sunshine
Posted 5:45 AM 1/8/08
A "couple of years" to write a spec? Seriously, it should take 1 day, 2 if you're lazy and want to do a spell check.
Little Mintz Sunshine
wharfrat
Posted 6:07 AM 1/8/08
"Hired to write a spec"? Isn't it one or the other?
wharfrat
Breadbowl
Posted 7:07 AM 1/8/08
Wasn't there a South Korean film called "Super Duper Bad Wrong Numbers" made in '99?
Breadbowl
juniperjenny
Posted 6:45 AM 1/8/08
@wharfrat: Yeah, that confused me too.
juniperjenny
Benny
Posted 11:18 AM 1/8/08
From Filmjunk:
"...this week some major press is being made accusing Judd Apatow of lifting the concept of "Knocked Up" from well known Canadian journalist Rebecca Eckler, Rebecca Eckler, who wrote a memoir called "Knocked Up: Confessions of a Hip Mother-to-be", released months before Apatow made his movie pitch. Eckler has enough credibility to make some noise here, and there are indeed similarities - a young journalist who had too much to drink only to be impregnated by a Jewish Canadian, aided by her sister."
Um... Far out.
The cover of her book is also identical to that of Judd's script, featuring a martini glass with a pacifier attached to the stem.
Benny
Benny
Posted 11:14 AM 1/8/08
Apatow is accused of stealing a hell of a lot.
There was that email fiasco between he and Mark Brazill about a sketch he did on The Ben Stiller Show, and a woman in Canada who wrote a book called 'Knocked Up' featuring a young pregnant entertainment journalist. Now this.
Is there any legitimacy to this stuff? I'm in no position to know, but it seems whenever I hear public accusations of concept theft Apatow is the accused. What's the deal Judd?
Benny