Resolution No. 1: Sarah Jessica Parker Censured for Complaining About Problems 'SATC' Helped Create
Posted by Defamer Hollywood at 2:15 AM on May 6, 2008
WHEREAS, it's not really our style to judge anyone before noon, especially on a Monday, but that's when New York Magazine happened to publish its new cover story about Sarah Jessica Parker; and
WHEREAS, Ms. Parker is the star of the Sex and the City, an overpraised television series adapted as an overhyped feature-length film for theatrical distribution later this month; and
WHEREAS, Sex and the City romantically represents contemporary New York City as a sanitized, upper-middle class shrine to culture, taste, privilege and glamor; and
WHEREAS, the real New York City is a class war waiting to happen, as exemplified by Ms. Parker's recollection to the author:
I don't know if you do this with your husband," Parker says. "But say one of us is walking down the street, I'll call him and say, 'You know, the laundromat is closed!' And he'll say, 'What?' I'll be like, 'The laundromat at 11th and West 4th Street is closed!' " and
WHEREAS, Ms. Parker's West Village walking tour is punctuated with other, similar laments, including those for the good old days of public insolvency and that "the city is so affluent, and all the colours, all the shops, the look of a street from block to block is just terribly absent of distinguishing coffee shops, bodegas. All of that stuff that made it possible to live in New York is gone ... I guess there are places in Queens that are affordable," and
WHEREAS, Ms. Parker acknowledges her calculated brand development (e.g. perfume, clothing line) within a half-dozen breaths of complaining about the media attention that reinforces it: "It makes me feel ashamed of my work. And I'm not. But I'm attached to this culture now in a way that, it's kind of vulgar. And I feel cheapened. And I feel like I'm cheapening the school, like I'm bringing dirt, like I'm bad for the neighborhood," and
WHEREAS, Ms. Parker is a confirmed nice person who, along with her nice husband Matthew Broderick, nevertheless symbolizes an urban idyll both contradictory and destructive to her self-proclaimed values, and
WHEREAS, we abhor hypocrisy among the West Village power elite and, more generally, among A-listers promoting their mass-market summer confections in major national publications,
NOW, THEREFORE, LET IT BE RESOLVED BY DEFAMER,
1. That Ms. Parker be censured for her perpetuation of Sex and the City and other utopian myths helping eviscerate New York in both the local and popular consciousness, and
2. That Ms. Parker be further censured for being the latest New Yorker to want things both ways, and
3. That this censure go forth in the form of an official editorial admonition: "Kindly shut the fuck up."
RESOLUTION PASSED this 5th day of May, 2008.
SIGNED,
DEFAMER

Comments (AU Comments · US Comments)
There are currently no AU comments for this post.
Shumina
Posted 2:56 AM 6/5/08
@Benny: But do we have to take anything at all from it? I mean *I* don't want to be a hypocrite when I say I don't know anything about that show and certainly don't think it has any influence on my life.
Shumina
Benny
Posted 2:44 AM 6/5/08
Meeting adjourned. But hey, isn't there something to be said for her at least acknowledging her hypocricy? Wanting it both ways may seem contradictory, but if both ways have pros and cons then it's actually the logical thing to do, right? I'll take genuine and inconsistent over consistently false.
Benny
johnbaptistephilouza
Posted 3:03 AM 6/5/08
This is the resolution that almost wasn't. Please publish Ms. Friedman's 24-hour Strom Thurmondesque filibuster.
johnbaptistephilouza
CourageousCoward
Posted 3:37 AM 6/5/08
@Fama Est: Unfortunately, this argument speaks to everyone as we're all guilty somehow or other (buy something made in China lately?)
CourageousCoward
Fama Est
Posted 3:33 AM 6/5/08
@Benny: As much as I'd like to think "genuine and inconsistent" was preferable (particularly since I've been personally guilty of it), the proliferation of the sin cum guilt combination is, I now suspect, the problem itself. The attitude is what, in the minds of the gentrifiers, licenses gentrification. It's the get-out-of-jail-free card that yuppies print and give to themselves, and just like a check without a bank, it has no currency. Morally, it makes no difference how you feel after you help gut a dry cleaner in favor of some chain store.
Fama Est
pureblarney
Posted 3:33 AM 6/5/08
As long as it's the last I hear of this movie that doesn't involve ads on scaffolding.
pureblarney
Tiger_Tanaka
Posted 4:19 AM 6/5/08
No one tell her that Soylent Green is made of people; that might push her over the edge.
Tiger_Tanaka
Benny
Posted 4:26 AM 6/5/08
I think that's true to an extent. But not everyone is just rationalizing, surely. Not everybody adopts the pose of guilt as a lifestyle choice, choosing its colour to match their sofa. Something of our moral consciousness has to be genuine, right?
Because if ones feelings ARE genuine, of course it matters how you feel after you perpetuate an ill. What you feel is the thing that happens before what happens next. Hopefully that will be redemptive action of some kind. Or if not, hypocrisy and worthiness of judgement. But sometimes, or often, it will be a combination of both. @Fama Est:
Benny
brilliantmistake
Posted 5:11 AM 6/5/08
Shouldn't her punishment be opening and working in a laundromat?
brilliantmistake
SanFranBetsu
Posted 5:27 AM 6/5/08
She is a self-loather.
SanFranBetsu
gwendolyn
Posted 5:59 AM 6/5/08
I enjoy knowing, as I read these little tidbits about SATC, that I never saw any more than 30 seconds of one episode of the TV show that birthed this movie...
Damned proud of it, I might add.
gwendolyn
thebullfrog
Posted 7:17 AM 6/5/08
People, relax. As one of the least necessary movies ever made AND a skyscraping turd of a failure, Ms. Parker will effectively censure HERSELF.
Besides the inevitable Lifetime Movie Network projects.
thebullfrog
SeaPeople
Posted 12:19 PM 6/5/08
Point of Inquiry- in what section will "the punch in the face" addendum be added?
SeaPeople
andria24
Posted 7:57 AM 6/5/08
OMG Defamer I love you.
Please, can we also point out how she says that people shouldn't have to pay outrageous amounts for fashion while she's wearing thousand-dollar shoes?
andria24
fembot
Posted 9:11 PM 10/5/08
@gwendolyn:
agreed.. now how about a resolution that she just shut up permanently/ totally..
fembot
lrubemp
Posted 6:43 AM 11/5/08
Lighten up. She's a grossly overpaid ACTRESS, not a real human, and dippy narcissism is part of the package. this is, after all, the same woman who blithely admitted she didn't even SEE Brokeback Mountain, but voted for Best Picture in 2006 anyway. Far bigger fish to fry elsewhere.
lrubemp
unclevanya
Posted 8:45 AM 11/5/08
She's such a paradox. Always appearing so "aw shucks smalltown girl from Ohio" and yet a minimogul. Starred in a show whose calling card is frank talk about (and depictions of) sex, but wouldn't do nudity. Says she's done no drugs, but also managed to live with Robert Downey Jr. for 6 years. In the 80s. Has always seemed like someone who is awkward and uncomfortable handling fame and success, yet became a fashion icon bigger than most turbodivas.
Why do I still like her so? Because I saw her in Annie when we were both kids?
Or maybe I just want her apartment...yeah, it's the apartment.
unclevanya
hitchenaride
Posted 6:19 AM 12/5/08
Why the hate on for SJP and SATC? Seriously, there are greater sins on all fronts
hitchenaride
MrRewrite
Posted 2:43 PM 12/5/08
Is there such a thing as a compassionate actress? Can you be self-absorbed and still self-aware and karmically-correct? What is narcissism anyways? Why do i sound like Carrie on SATC? (which i thought was Sex 'in' the city' for a long time)
MrRewrite